Showing posts with label felony. Show all posts
Showing posts with label felony. Show all posts

Sunday, June 3, 2018

County Prosecutor Tunheim Interview on the Issues


Above: Thurston County Courthouse sign directs visitors. A 2017 independent report says Thurston County Prosecuting Attorney Office practices contribute to slow case management. In an interview, Prosecuting Attorney Jon Tunheim touts new case management protocols and programs.

By Janine Gates
Little Hollywood

In his bid for a third term as Thurston County Prosecuting Attorney, Jon Tunheim is, for the first time, facing a challenger. 

In a recent interview with Tunheim, Little Hollywood focused on themes mentioned at his May 14 campaign kickoff party. It also took a deep dive into a 74 page independent report published in 2017 about Thurston County Superior Court felony case flow and calendar management.

Prosecutors in Washington State process all criminal cases, including those filed in Superior Court.

The report is particularly harsh in its findings about the Thurston County Prosecuting Attorney Office, saying the office does not have many policies in place that are standard best practices for trial courts.

Tunheim responded to the report and revealed new case management protocols currently underway.

National Center for State Courts (NCSC) Report

The report, published in June 2017 by the National Center for State Courts (NCSC), is titled “NCSC Felony Caseflow and Calendaring Study of Thurston County Superior Court.”

The consultants studied data and a sampling of cases within the prosecuting attorney’s office (TCPO), the public defender’s office (TCPD), and the court system, identifying a host of procedural and performance issues that causes delays, system inefficiencies, and productivity problems.

“Importantly, most everyone in the criminal justice system interviewed by the NCSC project team is dissatisfied with its functioning. To create the changes this report is recommending, every participant in the system, including the TCPO and the TCPD, must be willing to modify and reengineer their operations to improve overall system productivity for the public and for themselves,” it says.

The report is available online at http://www.co.thurston.wa.us/superior/documents/ncsc-report-20170601.pdf 

The NCSC consultants contend that lack of supervision of deputy prosecutors and ineffective pretrial conferences contribute to poor-quality decisions regarding which cases to take to trial. It also says there are too many trials. 

For those cases that do go to trial, approximately 50 percent end in not guilty findings or guilty findings to lesser charges.

Of 388 scheduled pretrial events, only 138 (35 percent) occurred on the date and time scheduled. The report says that this is a tremendously high percentage given the number of events that take place.

In blunt language, the report says that in-custody defendants’ length of stay at the jail is longer than it needs to be, the jail population is higher than it needs to be, and the current practices of the prosecuting attorney are a substantial cause of continuances, thus contributing to a slow case management system. 

Of the cases analyzed by NSCS investigators, the time from charging to disposition ranged from 28 days in a burglary case to 681 days in a drug sale case. Sex offense and drug sale/purchase cases took the longest to reach finality.

Pertaining to the handing over of case evidence, the discovery delivery process, the report illustrates communication difficulties between the prosecutor’s office and public defender’s office.

The report recommended that the prosecutor’s office overhaul its discovery delivery system to include a checklist so defense attorneys can see what is being delivered and is not yet delivered. This list should be entirely electronic, saying other counties have systems that could be copied.

“The Prosecutor believes in case management autonomy for his deputies. Although this may sound good in theory, in practice autonomy leads to large-scale plea agreement inconsistencies across his deputies. This is an issue of justice and fairness,” says the report.

To improve overall efficiencies, the report lists several major recommendations for the prosecutor’s office.


Above: Thurston County Prosecutor Jon Tunheim 
Photo by Janine Gates/Little Hollywood Media

Tunheim Responds To Report

In our interview, Tunheim was asked to respond to the report, which, to a layperson, appears particularly scathing toward the prosecutor’s office.

The report’s findings are important because the county’s criminal justice system eats up 76 percent of Thurston County’s general fund and the county commissioners are currently considering an expansion of the relatively new county jail. 

Tunheim said that “if there’s anything good that came out it [the report], everyone got their finger pointing done,” while pointing out the flaws in case flow and timeliness.

“There’s been a cultural issue with our Superior Court for a while now – nobody is holding anybody else accountable. It’s a delicate issue. Prosecutors and defenders work together in a relationship…of give and take on both sides…we try hard in this county to not be inappropriately adversarial. We try not to make it personal and try to understand each other’s hurdles.”

As a result of this relationship, Tunheim said there are continuances.

“Judges let lawyers make those decisions and were criticized in the report for not holding our feet to the fire,” he said.

Tunheim said he disagrees with the report’s comments on prosecution policy as there was no prosecutor involved in its writing.

“There were two consultants, a court administrator and a judge, both from large court systems. They are good system thinkers… (but)  I don’t feel like they understood that very well from a prosecutor’s perspective. Some things in there I just flat disagreed with on a philosophical policy level. All the system stuff about how we can move cases through – most of that I agree with.

“…There were admittedly things causing cases to be delayed. The discovery issues were less about discovery and more about when they get offers and are part of the negotiation process. We have been having a hard time getting discovery from the law enforcement agencies and that is putting some delay in our process because we can’t turn it over until we have it – and it takes time to do that,” said Tunheim.

New System Improvements

Tunheim says processes have improved since the report came out. New case management protocols which determine how a case moves through the system officially went live on June 1.

One of the recommendations in the report was for the process of discovery to be handled electronically.

“We all came to the table and came to specific agreements….The public defender’s office and the prosecutor’s office have been working together for the last six months to put a request for proposals out to get a new case management system that will hopefully be another improvement for all of us so we can exchange our discovery electronically, better schedule things and be all on the same page and use the system to better watch cases as they are moving through on the timeline.”

Felony Leadership Improvement Project (FLIP)

Tunheim described a new felony leadership improvement project (FLIP) that involves the leadership of the prosecutor’s office, public defender’s office, the court clerk, the court, jail, and pre-trial services to design a new case flow management system.

Meeting one and a half hours every month since last year, with a subcommittee meeting more frequently, part of their work is to set a realistic schedule for trial dates and design tracks for cases. The process is called differential case management - a good assessment at the very front of what a case might look like and how it might be resolved within a realistic timeframe.

Tunheim says a Thurston County murder case will take six months to a year to get to trial. A drug possession charge will take sixty to ninety days.

Addressing criticism in the report, Tunheim said he has felt unheard for a long time regarding the creation of a management system. 

In 2010, when another report was done about the court system, Tunheim said he advocated for a differential case management, but the court responded, “We don’t have the computer system to be able to do that.” Tunheim agreed it was a dinosaur of a system.

More case management fits and starts occurred as he worked with the previous county commissioner appointed public defender, Daryl Rodrigues, and it could never get rolled out.

“Finally, when the report came out, everyone was ok, let’s do this,” Tunheim says. He says the report unfairly implies that it’s the prosecutor’s office responsibility to develop a differential case management system.

“We can’t do that – it’s a system – so that’s why FLIP was so important – everyone finally came to the table and we were able to participate.”

First Look Unit

Tunheim’s new “First Look” unit is an idea that came out of the FLIP process. Its goal is to do a front end assessment of cases, contact the public defender’s office, and see which cases could be resolved quickly.

These cases often involve a significant addiction issue or are in need of some other kind of diversion. The unit’s purpose is to take a chunk of cases out of the system, so that the ones that are left get the prosecutor’s time and attention.

“Theft may be the case, but what (may be) driving it is the addiction…or maybe it comes in and nobody is arguing about what needs to happen, it just needs a plea offer to be made to see if we can resolve the case.”

Since January, about 150 cases have gone through the First Look process. It started with one deputy prosecuting attorney and Tunheim has since added two more, taking them away from other caseloads.

Tunheim credits one of his deputy prosecutors with coining the “First Look” phrase.

“I like it…it’s different. It proactively seeks out cases that could benefit from earlier resolution….I want to give it a very specific role and authority in the office…not make it just a process or a phone call.”

Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) Program

Tunheim was asked about the law enforcement assisted diversion (LEAD) program, a law enforcement led alternative to jail or other criminal justice response.

Tunheim took issue with points his challenger, Victor Minjares, made about it in an interview with Little Hollywood. Minjares had declared the county program a failure.

“I’m not ready to do that,” Tunheim said, saying it is a still a pilot project, begun last fall with the Lacey Police Department and the county sheriff’s department.

“It’s all set up, but we’re not getting the referrals from law enforcement. We’re still troubleshooting that…We’re in a way different environment than Seattle where it was created….We thought we could take this and do it on a county scale and that’s where we are running into our challenges. At the county, a deputy has someone in custody, and it’s easier for them to just take someone to jail and let the system work it out….Our feeling is that law enforcement doesn’t think it meets their needs right now.

“This may evolve, but if law enforcement would rather just take them to jail, our First Look program will take a look at the case and put it into community diversion.  Instead of charging them, release them from custody, and have mobile outreach meet them at the jail as they are being released to help them set up their plan. That’s our next step. I’m hopeful that will become our solution….We can make that happen. 

“That’s why I was concerned about the slow process. When FLIP is fully activated, that will reduce caseloads, and that burden will come down a little bit,” he said.

Speaking of caseloads, Little Hollywood asked about the morale of his team. 

In an office of 32 deputy prosecutors, 13 lawyers are assigned to felony cases. Last year, each deputy prosecutor had about 120 open felony cases at any one time.

The question led Tunheim into an animated conversation about the theory of hope.

Saying his style of leadership is driven by the concept of hope – the belief that the future can be better than the present and one’s ability to make it so, Tunheim says he has a good team that works well together. The office has experienced a very low turnover of lawyers over the past seven and a half years.

“We are creating a forward thinking culture for the community,” he said.



Editor’s Note/Clarification, June 4: In reference to the morale of Mr. Tunheim’s team and the number of open felony cases last year, Mr. Tunheim says each deputy prosecutor had 120 open felony cases, not a total caseload of 120 for the team. The reference has been corrected.

For more information about the campaign for Thurston County Prosecutor, go to “County Prosecutor Tunheim Defends Career, Successes,” at https://janineslittlehollywood.blogspot.com/2018/06/county-prosecutor-tunheim-defends.html and “Minjares Makes Case for Prosecuting Attorney Race,” at https://janineslittlehollywood.blogspot.com/2018/05/minjares-makes-case-for-prosecuting.html

Saturday, June 2, 2018

County Prosecutor Tunheim Defends Career, Successes


Above: Thurston County Prosecutor Jon Tunheim speaks at his campaign kick-off party held May 14 at St. Martin’s University in Lacey.

County Prosecutor Has Challenger in Reelection Campaign

By Janine Gates
Little Hollywood

“I was a soldier in the War on Drugs,” said Thurston County Prosecutor Jon Tunheim, speaking to a room of over 200 supporters at his campaign kick-off party held May 14 at St. Martin’s University in Lacey.

In his speech titled, “The Changing Notion of Justice,” Tunheim chronicled the role of prosecutors, the definition of justice, and changing attitudes toward issues of addiction and mental illness.

Defending his career in a campaign for re-election, Tunheim did not shy away from admitting his role as a tough prosecutor in the 1980s. He said he prosecuted criminals to the fullest extent of the law.

“The rhetoric was all about fighting the fight and winning the war. Justice for a prosecutor back then meant getting the conviction, getting that long sentence. Our performance was measured by conviction rates and sentence length….I tried a lot of cases and frankly, won most of them.”

Tunheim said he used to jokingly say that dismissal was not in his vocabulary.

Tunheim explained that while the crime rate has gone down, the national criminal justice system has become one without compassion and hope.

While some cases need a criminal justice resolution, Tunheim said, reform means changing the definition of a win, whether it means dismissing a case, getting someone into treatment or alternatives to correct issues, or not charging someone.

Citing reform effort successes, Tunheim mentioned the establishment of the Monarch Children’s Advocacy Center and the establishment of several alternative, therapeutic courts: drug, mental health, driving under the influence, and veteran’s court, the first such court in Washington State.

Tunheim touted Thurston County’s court programs as a model system and mentioned a new unit, called “First Look,” established to proactively identify cases that would be appropriate for diversion prior to charging.  He mentioned the creation of the Family Justice Center, construction of a new mental health triage unit, and a new case management protocol for felony cases.

“The new model of justice is smart on crime. Smart does not mean soft on crime….There is evil in this community…and prosecutors still need to be on the front line to protect the community from that evil,” he said.

While the crowd ate pulled pork sandwiches, baked beans and coleslaw, about 20 elected officials stood when recognized, as did about 12 deputy prosecuting attorneys. The other attorneys, Tunheim said, were doing their jobs, “keeping the community safe.”

In the end, Tunheim received a standing ovation.

The position of prosecuting attorney and the issues associated with it may not be on voters’ radar because current Thurston County prosecuting attorney Jon Tunheim has never had a challenger. Now he does.

Local attorney Victor Minjares, who is running on the issues of reform, respect, and justice, says there are serious issues with the criminal justice system in Thurston County.

Little Hollywood interviewed Minjares for an article posted May 3 at http://janineslittlehollywood.blogspot.com/2018/05/minjares-makes-case-for-prosecuting.html

Tunheim first took office in 2010 and is running for his third term. Each term is four years. Before Tunheim, Ed Holm had been prosecutor for three terms, from 1999 to 2010 and did not run for reelection. Tunheim, who was chief criminal deputy prosecutor at the time, ran for the position and won, and won reelection in 2014.

Tunheim first joined the Thurston County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office as a legal intern in 1988 and has won many awards for his community service.

Minjares and Tunheim are running as Democrats.

Coming Up Next: Little Hollywood recently interviewed Tunheim on themes mentioned at his campaign kickoff party and took a deep dive into a 2017 independent report about Thurston County Superior Court felony case flow and calendar management. Tunheim responds to the report, which is particularly harsh in its findings about the processes within the Thurston County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office. 

Above: Thurston County Prosecuting Attorney Jon Tunheim filled a room with supporters at his campaign kick-off party on May 14.



Editor’s Note/Clarifications, June 3: An edit was made to clarify that the treatment courts were established prior to Tunheim’s election as prosecuting attorney. An edit was also made to clarify that the Family Justice Center is not a jail program. It is a program that provides support and services to victims and survivors of domestic violence and human trafficking. It is located in the Family Support Center of South Sound and is a partnership between the Prosecutor’s Office, the Sheriff’s Office, the County Clerk’s Office and the Family Support Center.

Tuesday, November 15, 2016

Olympia Union Pacific Rail Blockade May Qualify as “Terrorist Attack”


Above: The railroad blockade continued in downtown Olympia on Tuesday. Early Tuesday, at 6:00 a.m., the Union Pacific police department served notice to protesters to vacate the tracks within two hours. They did not do so and Union Pacific officers did not come back. 

Port, Union Pacific, Olympia Police Departments Involved

By Janine Gates
www.janineslittlehollywood.blogspot.com

Editor's Note, November 16: Headline was changed from "Olympia Union Pacific Rail Blockade Qualifies as "Terrorist Attack" to "Olympia Union Pacific Rail Blockade May Qualify as "Terrorist Attack." Little Hollywood only cited one source for the legal information that was obtained from inside the blockade camp and provided to protesters on site. Little Hollywood appreciates the feedback.

The blockade of a Union Pacific train carrying ceramic proppants in downtown Olympia by protesters may qualify as a terrorist attack under federal codes and involves Port of Olympia security, the Union Pacific police department, and the City of Olympia police department.

Ceramic proppants are ceramic coated beads of sand created in China and used in the process of hydraulic fracking to allow for oil extraction. The train carrying the proppants from the Port of Olympia is destined for North Dakota's Bakken oil field. 

The evolving group of activists, collectively known as Olympia Stand, have created a camp on and near the tracks, and have increased their security measures. On environmental grounds, many are willing to risk arrest in a direct action to prevent the train from leaving Olympia. 

Climate scientists are clear that in order to stave off catastrophic climate change, 80 percent of fossil fuel reserves need to stay in the ground. 

In a press release issued November 13, the Olympia Stand group says it will continue to “fight the import or export of fossil fuel infrastructure until the Port of Olympia finds alternative uses for the marine terminal.”

Ports are considered separate municipalities, like a city or town, and have their own security force to protect port property. State law applies in ports, but some federal charges may also apply because ports are considered critical infrastructure of commerce. 

The Olympia Police Department has largely employed a hands-off approach, but officers have been seen in the area.

Little Hollywood asked the Olympia Police Department on Tuesday if it is cooperating with the Union Pacific Railroad special agents.

“We are working with Union Pacific Railroad police as well as working with other local agencies to ensure the city remains safe. Although the Union Pacific Railroad police department is the primary agency handling this matter and it is their jurisdiction right now, we recognize it is in the heart of our downtown and whatever comes of this will likely carry on to our city streets,” said public information officer Lt. Paul Lower.

“The group occupying the railroad tracks has put flyers up in a number of locations downtown Olympia which indicates they are unwilling to cooperate with anyone and will carry out their plan “by any means necessary,” using words such as “fight,” “attack,” and “fight back” to define what they mean. 

“The City of Olympia Police Department’s primary concern is the safety of our community. We are working hard to keep our community safe,” he added.

The encampment on the tracks has grown since the protest started last Friday.

Early Tuesday, at 6:00 a.m., protesters were served notice by two Union Pacific special agents based in Portland to vacate the railroad at 7th and Jefferson Street. Little Hollywood was told that one officer recorded the interaction with a camcorder.

Protesters were given a two hour warning and told to vacate by 8:00 a.m., however, railroad agents did not show up at 8:00 a.m.

There is a split in the railroad tracks between 7th and 8th Avenues in the area where the protesters are located. On Monday morning, protesters were contacted by another railroad company that operates a nearby track and were asked to untie a rope that was in the way of that railroad line’s property. 

The rope was anchoring a tent, and protesters untied the rope as requested without incident.

About that same time, a Port of Olympia inspector and a supervisor also showed up, along with Olympia Police Department officers, but there was no incident, and all officers left the scene.

Union Pacific Police Department History

Union Pacific has a police department staffed with more than 220 special agents, who are responsible for all Union Pacific locations across 32,000 miles of track in 23 states. 

Special agents have primary jurisdiction over crimes committed against the railroad and are certified state law enforcement officers with investigative and arrest powers both on and off railroad property in most states. They also have interstate law enforcement authority pursuant to federal law.

In 2014, the Union Pacific Police Department achieved accreditation from the Commission on Accreditation for Law Enforcement Agencies, Inc. (CALEA) for complying with the highest law enforcement standards. Only 17 percent of U.S. law enforcement agencies have earned the CALEA accreditation.

The railroad police force dates to the mid-1800s, when the number of U.S. Marshals was insufficient to police the country's growing rail network. Members were called Pinkertons, named after their originator, Alan Pinkerton.

Today, each Class I railroad employs special agents across the country to protect the rail network.

According to the Civil Liberties Defense Center, railroad tracks, and usually the land extending up to 50 feet on either side, are private property of railroad corporations.

Railroad police have interstate jurisdiction and can investigate and enforce all state law crimes against railroad whether or not the officers are on railroad property.

There are special state and federal charges that may be brought against protesters interfering with railroads and trains.

Federal charges typically involve the use of violence, but many non-violent actions may face serious charges and is written in a 1992 code rather broadly as
“terrorist attacks and other violence against railroad carriers and against mass transportation systems on land, on water, or through the air.”

Disabling, wrecking, or derailing any on-track equipment or vehicle, as well as making tracks, depots, bridges, tunnels, signals, warehouses, etc. unusable or unworkable also qualifies as a terrorist attack.

Also according to the Civil Liberties Defense Center, collecting information, surveilling, photographing, videotaping, or diagramming railroads or equipment to assist in any of this behavior may also qualify as a terrorist act, as does attempting, threatening, conspiring, or conveying false information about an attempt to do any of the above. 

All the above qualifies a Class C felony punishable by up to 20 years in prison and/or fines.

State charges also exist for railroad-specific behavior in Washington, including obstructing or delaying a train. This is a misdemeanor punishable by up to 90 days in jail and/or a $1,000 fine. 

For more photos and information about the rail blockade, Olympia Stand, the Port of Olympia, and ceramic proppants, go to Little Hollywood, www.janineslittlehollywood.blogspot.com, and type key words into the search button.

Wednesday, August 7, 2013

Case Closed: Yoos Pleads Guilty with Alford Plea


by Janine Unsoeld
www.janineslittlehollywood.blogspot.com

Scott Yoos, an Olympia man accused of a felony assault against a police officer, today pleaded guilty with an Alford plea to two counts, one for criminal trespass and one for obstructing a law enforcement officer.

In negotiations between Yoos, his attorney, Larry Hildes, and Thurston County Prosecuting Attorney J. Andrew Toynbee, the change in plea thus ended a 26 month ordeal for Yoos, and everyone else involved.

Yoos, 47, can hear, but cannot speak due to a head injury from a beating he suffered while hitchhiking in 1984.

On June 1, 2011, Yoos was cited for criminal trespass and obstructing justice while riding on his bicycle through Olympia at 11:30 p.m. toward his home on Martin Way. Yoos stopped to throw some dirty napkins in a Dumpster located at 2302 Fourth Avenue, near Twister Donuts, and within minutes, officers converged on Yoos. Yoos' method of communication, pen and paper, were taken away, and his attempts to communicate using sign language were interpreted by officers as violent behavior.

The case was bumped up to a felony after Olympia Police Department Sergeant Paul Johnson filed a report weeks after the situation, alleging that Yoos had kicked him during the scuffle. Yoos denies kicking Sergeant Johnson, and the alleged kick did not require medical attention.

Under the Alford plea, a defendant admits that sufficient evidence exists in which the prosecution could likely convince a judge or jury to find the defendant guilty if a case goes to trial. Yoos is contesting the facts but agreed that the facts in the police reports are sufficient that he could be found guilty. 

After several fitful starts, interruptions, and a court recess, Yoos, through a sign language interpreter, said today that he understood the rights he would give up by pleading guilty, and that the court did not need to necessarily adhere to the recommendations of the State, represented by Toynbee.

The five page document recommended, in part, that jail time be suspended, and that a $250 crime victim fund fee and a $200 filing fee be paid.

Judge Carol Murphy presided over the status hearing, saying that the court is not required to follow the State's recommendation. In the end, she did.

Hildes, in his statement on Yoos' behalf, said that Yoos has no criminal history, cares about his community, and that Yoos' biggest concern is to make sure that changes are made in law enforcement protocols, such as the use of police video cameras.

"He's one of the best hearted people I have ever met," said Hildes.

Yoos, through an interpreter, said to the court, "This whole thing has been very draining on many levels, physically and psychologically and financially, and I feel like I can no longer afford to swim in this pool. I want to see that video is installed in all of the OPD, Olympia Police Department, patrol cars or in the uniform. This all would never have happened if I had a recording, a recorded witness, to back me up. As it is now, it is four against one and my chances in trial would not be wonderful. It's very frustrating but I would be - I will be - happy to be done with this."

Murphy said that it is the court's opinion that Mr. Yoos has been very respectful in the courtroom, and consistently on time. She said she wished she could say the same for his attorney, Mr. Hildes, who often arrived late for court appearances. Hildes lives in Bellingham. 

She added that she appreciated Mr. Yoos' difficulty in navigating the justice system and the time it has taken for everyone to come to this resolution.

A Scott Yoos Legal Defense Fund account has been set up at the Washington State Employees Credit Union. To pay Yoos' remaining expenses as a result of his case, donations to the fund may be made at any credit union branch.

OPD and the Feasibility of Patrol Car Video Cameras

Asked by this reporter late last month about the Olympia Police Department's (OPD) time and costs expended by OPD on the Yoos case specifically, Laura Wohl, OPD's spokesperson, said she could not estimate the cost. 

"The reason that costs aren’t available is that we don’t track such things by the case. For example, we track overtime according to what it is used for generically: to fill short shifts, to staff events, for court time, etc. We don’t track straight time in a case-by-case manner, either. Instead, officers work on many things during their regular shifts and the time is simply noted as regular shift hours....They may be investigating multiple cases when they are in the field, at the same time they may need to respond to an emergency call."

Asked about the department's interest in and cost of video cameras in patrol cars, she said, "Yes, the department has investigated the use of video cameras in our vehicles. The cost of the equipment is approximately $6000 each plus one-time infrastructure (antennae, computer server for storing the video, etc.) costs of about $10,000. The department has received grant funding to buy up to six cameras, although we do not have funding to equip all of our cars."
 


Asked how many patrol cars there are in Olympia's fleet, Wohl said, "We currently have 20 marked patrol vehicles assigned to patrol shifts and to our traffic unit, as well as an additional two vehicles used by field supervisors. We have another 28 vehicles (some marked, some not) that are used by detectives, administration, the jail, the volunteer program, the school resource officer program, the training program, and our evidence/crime scene investigation team."
 
Wohl added, "OPD is in favor of in-car video. We believe that it provides important information about incidents that happen in the field that helps protect both citizens and officers. We had planned to implement in-car video in 2012 with the funding we had identified. However, staffing shortages and other high-priority projects delayed implementation."
 
"Recently, court decisions have raised questions about the retention of in-car videos. Additional retention requirements may significantly impact the workload needed to manage the storage and dissemination of in-car videos. We are still assessing what resources would be required to manage the videos and whether an in-car video program is feasible," Wohl said.

For more information and several articles about Yoos' case, use the search button and use key words on this blog at ww.janineslittlehollywood.blogspot.com.

Wednesday, July 24, 2013

Yoos Case: Motion To Dismiss Denied


Yoos Case: Motion To Dismiss Denied
By Janine Unsoeld
www.janineslittlehollywood.blogspot.com

The motion to dismiss a felony case against Scott Yoos, an Olympia man who is mute, was denied yesterday by Thurston County Superior Court Judge Christine Pomeroy.  
A date of August 12 has been set for the case to now go to trial with a twelve person jury.  This date could be changed if Yoos' attorney, Larry Hildes, asks for a delay to prepare for the case.
Yoos, 47, can hear, but cannot speak due to a head injury from a beating he suffered in 1984. (For more information and several articles about Yoos' case, use the search button and use key words on this blog at www.janineslittlehollywood.blogspot.com).

Immediately following the court's decision, Yoos motioned this reporter to come over and read what he was writing.
 
"The city of Olympia needs video cameras - I would have been entirely vindicated with a recorded witness, either on the patrol cars or attached to officer's uniforms. I've seen some very sophisticated cameras under $1,000 each."
 
Asking him what he does now, Yoos wrote, “I’ll scheme with the attorney, hopefully rest a bit.”


Case History

 
Accused of a felony assault against a police officer, Yoos was initially cited for criminal trespass and obstructing justice on June 1, 2011. On that date, Yoos was riding on his bicycle through downtown Olympia at 11:30 p.m. toward his home on Martin Way, when he stopped to throw some dirty napkins in a Dumpster located at 2302 Fourth Avenue, near Twister Donuts, in Olympia.

Within minutes, several officers converged on Yoos. Yoos’ method of communication, pen and paper, were taken away, and his attempts to communicate using sign language were interpreted by officers as violent behavior.  Yoos is 5'9 and weighs about 155 pounds.

The case was bumped up to a felony after Olympia Police Department Sergeant Paul Johnson filed a report weeks after the situation, alleging that Yoos had kicked him during the scuffle. The alleged kick did not require medical treatment. Yoos denies kicking Sergeant Johnson.

Yoos’ case has dragged on for 26 months. There have been repeated delays in the case, many of them because a court-appointed sign language interpreter was not provided or available.  Larry Hildes, his attorney, has repeatedly asked the court for a motion to dismiss the case, based on discriminatory actions by the arresting law enforcement officers.
In what has amounted to several days of actual testimony in which Yoos and three law enforcement officers involved in the case testified, Olympia Police Department officers Officer Randy Wilson, Officer S. Costello, and Officer Jason Watkins, Judge Pomeroy ruled that the officers’ actions were justified, and that they had a reasonable right to stop and detain Mr. Yoos.  She further explained that their actions were not discriminatory, citing, in the court’s opinion, that it was Mr. Yoos’ repeated attempts to leave the scene that made the situation escalate.

Hildes repeatedly argued that Yoos was unjustly arrested and silenced because the officers did not have the proper training to deal with Yoos’ disability, and, after the officers made a series of assumptions, allowed the situation to escalate.
In his closing arguments, Hildes was assertive, saying in part, "Officers are supposed to deescalate situations...It became a power struggle, respect for the officers, forcing him to do what they wanted him to do and he just wanted to communicate, that's the discrimination. But for the lack of training, experience, and policy, there would not have been an incident. Dismiss this case. But for the discriminatory result, there would be no case...."
Thurston County prosecuting attorney J. Andrew Toynbee, appearing cool and calm in his demeanor, said in his closing argument, in part, "...over three days, the officers have testified and are able to give you a reason for everything...I'm telling the court they did nothing wrong. The defendant did not wish to communicate. In fact, he kept trying to leave...when asked, he did not write his name and birthdate...they had business to conduct with him. They had a reason to talk with him...there was not a lack of training or desire to communicate...he kept trying to leave....this was a dynamic situation, things happened quickly."
Citing case law, Toynbee said that the officers had justification to take action and it had nothing to do with discrimination against Mr. Yoos.
Hildes argued that it was not a dynamic situation, that they were standing there having a written exchange until Officer Wilson intentionally took his pad of paper away, preventing Yoos from further communication.
"This was like putting a gag in his mouth, intentionally using his disability against him."
Sample Testimony
Today, two sign language interpreters were available to accommodate Yoos’ method of sign language, which is signs and finger spelling. The process is time-consuming. When changes in words occurs, it is not clear if it is Yoos changing what he is saying or if the sign language interpreter misinterpreted his finger spelling. Yoos quickly corrected the interpreter if she misinterpreted his words.

The following is a portion of an unofficial transcription as heard and written by this reporter of yesterday's testimony by Yoos, when questioned by his attorney.

Hildes: Were you trying to be uncooperative?

Yoos: No, I just wanted to go home to bed and it was a little frightening to have this armed man immediately arrest me and accuse me of something that I had not done.

Hildes: Did you attempt to communicate that to him?
Yoos: I had my communication tools all taken away from me and I was just trying to sign to them.

Hildes: Did they stop trying to communicate to you at that point?
Yoos: They were interested in arresting me and attacking me.

Moments later:
Hildes: Did you attempt to leave?

Yoos: I didn’t try to “leave” three times like Costello claims that I – no, no.
Later:

Hildes: At the time, if they had communicated with you, would you have communicated with them?
Yoos: I am not a criminal. I am a former Eagle Scout, so, and preacher’s kid. I never threatened any of the police officers.

Hildes: Was it your intention to resist them?
Yoos: No, I didn’t think it was right for them to steal my bicycle and my Walkman, my wallet, my bag and all of the papers I had in my backpack and in my pocket.

Hildes: What made you think they were stealing?
Yoos: When someone violently takes something from you, that’s stealing.

Hildes: Why did you feel like it was stealing?
Yoos: I did nothing wrong and I couldn’t communicate and it was very frustrating to me.

Hildes: Were you frightened?
Yoos: Of course – there were four armed men.

Hildes: What were you wearing – what did you have on your feet?
Yoos: I was riding my bicycle with lightweight sandals like TEVA’s but cheaper.

Hildes: And you were wearing a reflective vest, correct?
Yoos: Yes.

Hildes: So you weren’t trying to sneak into the parking lot?
Yoos: No, of course not.

Hildes: So you weren’t trying to break into the donut shop?
Yoos: Please, no.

Later:
Hildes: Did you ever attempt to resist the officers?

Yoos: I only tried to communicate with Watkins by pulling in my arms so they could not cuff me again.
Hildes: Why did you do that?

Yoos: Because I needed to tell them – I needed my voice.
Hildes: So you were just trying to communicate?

Yoos: Yes.

Later:

Hildes: What frightened you about this incident?
Yoos: I had been – I was being – unjustly arrested and accused of things which I was not guilty of and physically, and I was having armed men approaching me at night.

Hildes: Was it also because they took away your ability to communicate?
Yoos: That was very frightening and frustrating to me…it was Wilson who took the pad and my communication away.

Hildes: So the officer already did that?
Yoos: Yes.

Hildes: And you were already communicating with him about the incident when he took the pad away from you?
Yoos: Yea, briefly. There are only, like, two or three back and forth conversations.

Later:
Hildes: He could have kept on writing and you would have kept responding, right?

Yoos:  Yes.
Hildes: Did you give him any reason that you didn’t want to communicate with him?

Yoos: I just wanted to go back home….I felt threatened and harassed but I was entirely willing to write back and forth with him.

With his attorney and friends, and while seated with his interpreter during the hearing, Yoos was using a new gizmo to communicate, a little black  LCD writing tablet called a Boogie Board. One button touch erases his words between thoughts. Asked about it during a break, Yoos wrote, “It was a surprise gift from a friend’s friend who won it in a raffle and sent it to me in the mail from Texas.”
Asked how he likes it, Yoos wrote, “It’s low battery use, it’s “supposed” to go about six years. It is the bottom of the line cheapest model  - he points to the back that says it’s from www.improveelectronics.com - but it’s just what I need. A lot better from markers, cuz those are very messy and are always drying out on me. Plus, no fumes.”  Many of his friends had difficulty reading the dark blue lettering against the black board but took the time to read his writings.

Yoos looked pale and drawn. During another break, he was asked how he feels. He wrote that his red nose and sniffles was the result of allergies.

Asked how he is holding up in general, Yoos wrote, “It’s been hanging over me for 26 months with over 20 court appearances counting the city ones – s’been hellacious – I’m not able to consider adopting a pup….”
 
Interview with Thurston County Prosecuting Attorney J. Andrew Toynbee


In a telephone interview this morning with Thurston County Chief Prosecuting Attorney J. Andrew Toynbee, who has pursued and argued the case against Yoos, Toynbee was asked what happens next. 


Toynbee said the case is scheduled to go to trial and Yoos could be convicted of assault of the third degree with a sentence of one to three months in jail, acquitted, or, he could accept a plea offer to a lesser charge.

“I’m not interested in sending Mr. Yoos to jail,” said Toynbee.  “I have made several attempts for plea offers in the past but Mr. Yoos’ attorney, Larry Hildes, has not entertained them.”

Asked why Thurston County is pursuing this case, Toynbee said, “We take assaults on officers very, very seriously, that’s the reason."
Asked what he wants from Yoos, Toynbee responded, “My goal is to have Mr. Yoos take some accountability for his actions.”

Asked why Sergeant Paul Johnson, the officer who was allegedly kicked by Yoos, did not testify, Toynbee said, “The motion only focused on one issue – whether law enforcement was discriminatory in their actions. Sergeant Johnson didn’t take action, he oversaw the situation after he arrived, but he would be called to trial. He could have testified, but it (the hearing) was going on and on….”

Asked if he thinks it’s a problem that Sergeant Johnson’s report is dated weeks after the incident, (it is dated June 27), and unsigned, Toynbee said, “No, I don’t think it’s a problem. Two officers, Costello and Wilson saw it (the kick).”

Asked how much Thurston County has spent thus far on Yoos’ case, Toynbee said he is a salaried employee and doesn’t know how much has been spent.